Milkshakes

For over 35 years, Justine’s has been blending up milkshake magic. We crafted over 50 signature shakes including some seasonal favorites. Now, our menu has grown to feature more than 90 classic and signature milkshakes to choose from! Justine’s “Famous Wall of Shakes” has captured national attention, earning recognition in major publications like The Chicago Tribune, Life Magazine, Chocolatier Magazine, The New York Times, and The Philadelphia Inquirer.

Milkshakes Sizes

All Classic, Signature and Top Tier Shakes come in two different sizes. The small size is 16 oz and the Large size is 24 oz.

Classic Shakes

Select any of the 42 available hand dipped ice cream flavors, including soft serve ice cream. Additional charge for mixing 2 flavors.

Check flavors.

Justine’s Famous Wall of Shakes

  • Black & White Shake

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Banana Split Shake (TT)

    A creamy blend of sliced banana, strawberry ice cream, and rich chocolate syrup—topped with fluffy whipped cream and a cherry on top.

  • Brown Cow

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with flavorful root beer syrup.

  • Caramel Covered Pretzel (TT)

    Sweet & Salty Caramel Pretzel/ Vanilla Bean ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and caramel sauce, topped with pretzels and caramel covered pretzel rod.

  • Chocolate Covered Cherry

    Cherry ice cream with real cherry pieces, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Covered Marzipan

    Pistachio Almond ice cream with real pistachios, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Covered Pretzel (TT)

    Sweet & Salty Caramel Pretzel/ Classic Chocolate ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and rich chocolate syrup, topped with pretzels and chocolate covered pretzel rod.

  • Chocolate Covered Strawberry

    Naturally flavored strawberry ice cream with bits of real strawberry, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Monkey Shake

    Creamy classic chocolate and banana ice cream blended with a fresh banana for a rich and fruity treat.

  • Chocolate Skippy

    Classic Chocolate/ Chocolate PB ice cream, mixed with extra creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • Coco-Oh Rum

    Rum ice cream with real raisins, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Cocoa-Coconut

    Smooth and creamy coconut ice cream, blended with rich chocolate syrup,topped with coconut flakes.

  • Coffee Toffee (TT)

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with Heath Bar, Butterscotch sauce, topped with whipped cream, Butterscotch and dusting of Heath Bar.

  • Creamsicle

    Justine’s signature shake, created in 1989. A flavorful Vanilla Bean/Orange blend, mixed with Justine’s secret ingredient and orange juice.

  • Creamy Lemon Pie (TT)

    Rich  vanilla and lemon ice cream, swirled with crunchy graham cracker pieces, topped with  whipped cream and a light dusting of graham cracker crumbs.

  • Express Shake (TT)

    Creamy Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with a shot of Italian Espresso, topped with whipped cream.

  • Fruity Pebble Shake (TT)

    Smooth, creamy vanilla bean ice cream mixed with plenty of Fruity Pebbles, topped with swirl of whipped cream and an extra Fruity Pebbles for a colorful crunch.

  • German Chocolate Shake (TT)

    Justine’s specialty mix of ice creams, blended with rich hot fudge sauce, topped with whipped cream and coconut flakes.

  • Hot Chocolate Shake

    Rich Classic Chocolate ice cream, blended with Cayenne, topped with dusting of Cayenne. Optional mix-in – extra Cayenne.

  • Hot Fudge Sundae Shake (TT)

    Chocolate Chip ice cream, blended with rich hot fudge sauce and malt, topped with whipped cream and a cherry.

  • Key Lime Shake (TT)

    Refreshing Lemon sorbet and Vanilla ice cream, lime syrup, blended with graham crackers, topped with whipped cream and a light dusting of graham cracker crumbs.

  • Latte-Da Express (TT)

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with a shot of Italian Espresso.

  • Loca Mocha

    Indulge in the bold flavor of rich coffee ice cream, perfectly blended with decadent chocolate syrup.

  • Madras Shake

    Raspberry Sorbet and Orange sherbet, blended with seltzer water.

  • Malt

    Classic chocolate or creamy vanilla bean ice cream, blended with smooth malt powder. Or make it your own—create a malted milkshake with your favorite ice cream flavor!

  • Mandarin Shake

    Rich classic chocolate mixed with orange juice.

  • Millenniyum

    Peach flavor with bits of peaches, blended with fresh orange juice.

  • Mint Chocolate Covered Oreo

    Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream , blended with rich chocolate syrup and loaded with extra Oreos.

  • Minted Coffee

    A bold blend of cool mint chocolate chip ice cream and rich, smooth coffee ice cream—where refreshing meets robust.

  • Mocha Express (TT)

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with a shot of Italian espresso.

  • Mocha Oreo

    Decadent chocolate ice cream blended with a generous amount crushed Oreos for the ultimate chocolate cookies-and-cream overload.

  • Mud Slide (TT)

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with Oreo’s, rich hot fudge sauce and a shot of Italian espresso, topped with whipped cream and oreos.

  • Muscle Beach (TT)

    A refreshing blend of fresh banana, creamy strawberry ice cream, and a boost of 25g of whey protein—perfectly mixed for flavor and fuel.
    Topped with a swirl of whipped cream, it’s the ultimate treat for anyone craving something sweet with a protein-packed punch.

  • Orange Freeze

    Refreshing blend of Rainbow Sherbet and orange juice.

  • PB Express

    A smooth blend of classic vanilla peanut butter ice cream and a bold shot of Italian espresso, topped with a swirl of whipped cream.
    Rich, creamy, and perfectly caffeinated—it’s the ultimate pick-me-up for peanut butter lovers.

  • Peach Melba Shake

    Peach/Raspberry ice cream mix with bits of peaches, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Peanut Butter Covered Pretzel (TT)

    Vanilla/Peanut Butter ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and creamy peanut butter, topped with pretzels and peanut butter covered pretzel rod.

  • Peanut Butter Jelly Shake

    Vanilla/PB ice cream, blended with strawberry sauce and creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • Pina Colada (TT)

    Exquisite blend of Coconut/Pineapple, topped with coconut flakes, whipped cream and a cherry.

  • Raspy Cookie

    Smooth black raspberry  ice cream, blended with  crushed Oreos.

  • Sinnamon Toast (TT)

    Vanilla Bean/Cinnamon mix, blended with graham crackers, topped with extra graham crackers, whipped cream and dusting of cinnamon.

  • Vanilla Monkey Shake

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean,blended with a real banana.

  • Vanilla Skippy Shake

    Vanilla/Peanut Butter ice cream, mixed with extra creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • White & Black

    Rich classic chocolate, blended with luscious vanilla syrup.

  • Wild Bull

    Velvety classic chocolate ice cream perfectly blended with bold, fizzy root beer syrup for a nostalgic twist.