ice-cream-flavors

Hand-Dipped Ice Cream

Justine’s Ice Cream Parlour OC offers over 42 premium flavors including hand-dipped ice cream, soft serve ice cream, frozen yogurts, sorbet (non-dairy choice) and sherbets. We also offer no sugar added, reduced fat, fat free and non-diary options. The availability of these flavors varies through the season.

If you have any questions regarding availability of a flavor,please give us a call on:
410 250 5003

* – When Available, ** – Seasonal, RF – Reduced Fat, FF – Fat Free, NSA – No Sugar Added

Premium Ice Cream Flavors:

  • BANANA

    Banana ice cream flavored with banana puree.

  • BANANA SPLIT*

    Banana ice cream with strawberry pieces and a fudge swirl

  • BING CHERRY

    Vanilla ice cream with real cherry pieces.

  • BIRTHDAY CAKE

    Cake batter flavored ice cream with blue frosting swirl and confetti sprinkles.

  • BLACK RASPBERRY

    Black raspberry flavored ice cream.

  • BLUEBERRY CHEESECAKE**

    Cheesecake flavored ice cream with blueberry ribbons and graham pieces.

  • BOURBON ON THE ROCKS

    Bourbon flavored ice cream  with butterscotch swirl.

  • BUTTER PECAN

    Pecan flavored ice cream with pecan slices.

  • CARAMEL CARIBOU

    Toffee ice cream with a thick caramel swirl and milk chocolate caramel cups.

  • CHOCOLATE

    Rich, smooth naturally flavored chocolate ice cream.

  • CHOCOLATE CHIP

    Vanilla ice cream with chunks of chocolate chips.

  • CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE DOUGH

    Vanilla ice cream with chips and cookie dough.

  • CHOCOLATE/PB SWIRL

    Chocolate ice cream with a peanut butter swirl.

  • CHOCOLATE SWEET&SALTY CARAMEL PRETZEL*

    Chocolate ice cream swirled with ribbons of caramel and loaded with chocolate covered pretzels.

  • COCONUT

    Coconut flavored ice cream.

  • COFFEE

    Rich coffee flavored ice cream.

  • COOKIE-CRUNCH CARAMEL*

    Caramel flavored ice cream with a chocolate swirl and vanilla cookie pieces.

  • COOKIES & CREAM

    Vanilla ice cream with chocolate cookie pieces.

  • COTTON CANDY

    Pink cotton candy that contains color coated mini chocolate chips.

  • CRAZY VANILLA*

    Creamy vanilla ice cream with a colorful mix of pink, yellow, and blue bursts.

  • DOUBLE FUDGE BROWNIE

    Rich fudge ice cream with chunky brownie pieces.

  • DULCE DE LECHE

    Sweet milk ice cream swirled with a rich, creamy, decadent caramel.

  • EGG NOG**

    Rich, creamy egg nog flavored ice cream.

  • ESPRESSO CHIPS

    Natural coffee flavored ice cream that contains espresso chocolatey chips.

  • FROZEN HOT CHOCOLATE

    Hot chocolate flavored ice cream with marshmallow and chocolate chips.

  • MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP

    Mint ice cream with chunks of chocolate chips.

  • MOOSETRACKS

    Vanilla ice cream with Moose Tracks fudge and peanut butter cups.

  • MOOSETRACKS* NSA/RF

    No Sugar Added, Reduced Fat vanilla ice cream with Moose Tracks fudge and peanut butter cups.

  • PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE

    Vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter swirl.

  • PISTACHIO

    Green pistachio ice cream with real pistachio pieces.

  • PUMPKIN**

    Pumpkin flavored ice cream.

  • RED VELVET*

    Red velvet flavored ice cream with a cream cheese frosting swirl and Red Velvet cake bits.

  • ROCKY ROAD

    Natural chocolate ice cream with marshmallow swirl and almonds.

  • RUM RAISIN

    Rum flavored ice cream with real raisins.

  • SPUMONI**

    French vanilla and pistachio ice cream with fruit, almonds and pistachios.

  • STRAWBERRY

    Naturally flavored strawberry ice cream with bits of real strawberry.

  • STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE**

    Cheesecake ice cream with a strawberry swirl.

  • STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE**

    Vanilla ice cream a strawberry swirl, strawberry & vanilla crunchies.

  • SWEET&SALTY CARAMEL PRETZEL

    Vanilla ice cream swirled with ribbons of caramel and loaded with chocolate covered pretzels.

  • VANILLA BEAN

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean.

  • VANILLA FF/NSA

    Fat Free, No Sugar added flavored vanilla ice cream.

Premium Frozen Yogurt :


  • PEACH (Frozen Yogurt)

    Naturally flavored peach yogurt with bits of peaches.

  • PEANUT BUTTER (Frozen Yogurt)*

    Low fat vanilla yogurt with a thick peanut butter swirl.

  • HEATH CANDY Yougurt * RF

    Toffee yogurt with a thick caramel swirl and milk chocolate caramel cups.

Sorbet & Sherbet:

  • LEMON (Sorbet)

    Non-dairy lemon flavored sorbet.

  • PASSION FRUIT (Sorbet)*

    Non-dairy passion fruit flavored sorbet.

  • RASPBERRY (Sorbet)

    Dairy free raspberry flavored sorbet.

  • LEMON LIME (Sherbet)

    Lemon and Lime flavored Sherbet.It contains small amount of milk.

  • ORANGE (Sherbet)

    Orange flavored Sherbet.It contains small amount of milk.

  • PINEAPPLE (Sherbet)*

    Pineapple flavored Sherbet.It contains small amount of milk.

  • RAINBOW (Sherbet)

    Raspberry, Lime and Orange flavored Sherbet.It contains small amount of milk.

Soft Serve:

  • VANILLA

    Vanilla flavored, premium 10% butterfat soft serve ice cream.

  • CHOCOLATE

    Chocolate flavored, premium 10% butterfat soft serve ice cream.

  • TWIST

    Twist of vanilla and chocolate flavored, premium 10% butterfat soft serve ice cream.

We serve in a cup or in a cone. No charge for plain cake or sugar cones. Additional charge for waffle cones and specialty cones.

>

sundaes

Classic Ice Cream Sundaes

All sundaes are served with whipped cream and a cherry. You can select your ice cream flavors.One flavor in a dip.

    • Hot Fudge Sundae

      Two big dips of ice cream, covered with fresh hot fudge.

    • Terrapin Sundae

      Two big dips of ice cream, topped with butterscotch, fresh hot fudge and wet walnuts .

    • Dusty Road Sundae

      Two big dips of ice cream, covered with caramel, fresh hot fudge and dusting of malt .

    • Hawaian Luau

      Two big dips of ice cream, topped with pineapple sauce, coconut flakes and chopped peanuts .

    • CMP

      Two big dips of ice cream, topped with chocolate, marshmallow and chopped peanuts.

    • BMP

      Two big dips of ice cream, covered with butterscotch, marshmallow and chopped peanuts.

  • Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae

    A warm chocolate chip brownie with hot fudge layer, topped with 2 dips of ice cream, covered with hot fudge .

  • Street Rod

    One big dips of ice cream, topped with one topping, served in a street rod.

  • Pirate Ship

    Two big dips of ice cream, topped with two toppings.

Custom Ice Cream Sundaes

Create you own sundae with your favorite ice cream flavors and toppings. All sundaes are served with whipped cream and a cherry.

  • 1 Scoop 1 Topping

    Customize your sundae.

  • 1 Scoop 2 Toppings

    Customize your sundae.

  • 2 Scoops 2 Toppings

    Customize your sundae.

  • Customize your sundae.

    2 Scoops 3 Toppings

Jumbo Ice Cream Sundaes

Create you own sundae with your favorite ice cream flavors and toppings. All sundaes are served with whipped cream and a cherry.

    • Banana Boat

      Two dips of ice cream, two toppings and a banana.

    • Banana Yacht

      Three dips of ice cream, three toppings and a banana.

    • Kick the Bucket

      Four big dips of ice cream with two toppings, served in a bucket.

    • Justine’s Grande (sampler)

      Eleven (11) kiddie scoops of ice cream, served in a bucket.

    • The Titanic

      Eight huge scoops of ice cream, topped with six toppings, 4 cake cones and an iceberg of whipped cream, served in big bucket.



Milkshakes

For over 30 years, we’ve been crafting unforgettable shakes, with more than 35 signature creations that have delighted our customers. Today, we proudly offer over 77 classic and signature milkshakes. Justine’s Famous Wall of Shakes has earned recognition in esteemed publications like The Chicago Tribune, Life Magazine, Chocolatier Magazine, The New York Times, and The Philadelphia Inquirer, solidifying its place as a beloved local and national sensation.

Milkshakes Sizes

All Classic, Signature and Top Tier Shakes come in two different sizes. The small size is 16 oz and the Large size is 24 oz.

Classic Shakes

Select any of the 42 available hand dipped ice cream flavors, including soft serve ice cream. Additional charge for mixing 2 flavors.

Check flavors.

Justine’s Famous Wall of Shakes

  • Black & White Shake

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Black Raspberry Oreo

    Smooth black raspberry flavored ice cream, blended with exquisite Peach Melba sauce and crushed Oreo’s.

  • Brown Cow

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with flavorful root beer syrup.

  • Caramel Covered Pretzel

    Sweet & Salty Caramel Pretzel/ Vanilla Bean ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and caramel sauce, topped with caramel covered pretzel rod.

  • Chocolate Covered Cherry

    Cherry ice cream with real cherry pieces, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Covered Marzipan

    Pistachio ice cream with real pistachios, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Covered Pretzel

    Sweet & Salty Caramel Pretzel/ Classic Chocolate ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and rich chocolate syrup, topped with chocolate covered pretzel rod.

  • Chocolate Covered Strawberry

    Naturally flavored strawberry ice cream with bits of real strawberry, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Monkey Shake

    Classic Chocolate ice cream, blended with a real banana.

  • Chocolate Skippy

    Classic Chocolate/ Chocolate PB ice cream, mixed with extra creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • Coco-Oh Rum

    Rum ice cream with real raisins, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Cocoa-Coconut

    Smooth and creamy coconut ice cream, blended with rich chocolate syrup,topped with coconut flakes.

  • Coffee Toffee

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with Heath Bar, Butterscotch sauce, topped with whipped cream, Butterscotch and dusting of Heath Bar.

  • Creamsicle

    Justine’s signature shake, created in 1989. A flavorful Vanilla/Orange blend, mixed with secret ingredient and orange juice.

  • Creamy Lemon Pie

    Rich and creamy vanilla soft serve/ Lemon ice cream, blended with graham crackers, topped with whipped cream and dusting of graham crackers.

  • Express Shake

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with a shot of Italian Espresso, topped with whipped cream.

  • Expresso De Leche

    Dolche De Leche ice cream, blended with a freshly made Italian espresso.

  • German Chocolate Shake

    Justine’s specialty mix of ice creams, blended with rich hot fudge sauce, topped with whipped cream.

  • Hot Chocolate Shake

    Rich Classic Chocolate ice cream, blended with Cayenne, topped with dusting of Cayenne. Optional mix-in – extra Cayenne.

  • Hot Fudge Sundae Shake

    Chocolate Chip ice cream, blended with rich hot fudge sauce and malt, topped with whipped cream and a cherry.

  • Key Lime Shake

    Refreshing Lemon/Lime ice cream, blended with graham crackers, topped with whipped cream and dusting of graham crackers.

  • Latte Express

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with a shot of Italian Espresso.

  • Madras Shake

    Raspberry and Orange sorbet, blended with seltzer water. A diary free shake.

  • Mandarin Shake

    Classic chocolate mixed with orange juice.

  • Millennium

    Peach flavor with bits of peaches, blended with fresh orange juice.

  • Mint Chocolate Covered Oreo

    Mint/ Oreo’s ice cream mix, blended with rich chocolate syrup and extra Oreo’s.

  • Mocha Express

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with a shot of Italian espresso.

  • Mocha Shake

    Rich coffee flavored ice cream, blended with delicious chocolate syrup.

  • Mud Slide

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with Oreo’s, rich hot fudge sauce and a shot of Italian espresso, topped with whipped cream and Oreo’s.

  • Orange Freeze

    Refreshing blend of Rainbow Sherbet and orange juice.

  • Peach Melba Shake

    Peach/Raspberry ice cream mix with bits of peaches, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Peanut Butter Covered Pretzel

    Vanilla/Peanut Butter ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and creamy peanut butter, topped with peanut butter covered pretzel rod.

  • Peanut Butter Jelly Shake

    Vanilla/PB ice cream, blended with strawberry sauce and creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • Pina Colada

    Exquisite blend of Coconut/Pineapple, topped with coconut flakes, whipped cream and a cherry.

  • Sinnamon Toast

    Vanilla Bean/Cinnamon mix, blended with graham crackers, topped with extra graham crackers, whipped cream and dusting of cinnamon.

  • Vanilla Monkey Shake

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean,blended with a real banana.

  • Vanilla Skippy Shake

    Vanilla/Peanut Butter ice cream, mixed with extra creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • White & Black

    Classic chocolate, blended with luscious vanilla syrup.

  • Wild Bull

    Rich classic chocolate ice cream blended with root beer syrup.



Milkshakes

For over 30 years, we’ve been crafting unforgettable shakes, with more than 35 signature creations that have delighted our customers. Today, we proudly offer over 77 classic and signature milkshakes. Justine’s Famous Wall of Shakes has earned recognition in esteemed publications like The Chicago Tribune, Life Magazine, Chocolatier Magazine, The New York Times, and The Philadelphia Inquirer, solidifying its place as a beloved local and national sensation.

Milkshakes Sizes

All Classic, Signature and Top Tier Shakes come in two different sizes. The small size is 16 oz and the Large size is 24 oz.

Classic Shakes

Select any of the 42 available hand dipped ice cream flavors, including soft serve ice cream. Additional charge for mixing 2 flavors.

Check flavors.

Justine’s Famous Wall of Shakes

  • Black & White Shake

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Black Raspberry Oreo

    Smooth black raspberry flavored ice cream, blended with exquisite Peach Melba sauce and crushed Oreo’s.

  • Brown Cow

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with flavorful root beer syrup.

  • Caramel Covered Pretzel

    Sweet & Salty Caramel Pretzel/ Vanilla Bean ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and caramel sauce, topped with caramel covered pretzel rod.

  • Chocolate Covered Cherry

    Cherry ice cream with real cherry pieces, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Covered Marzipan

    Pistachio ice cream with real pistachios, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Covered Pretzel

    Sweet & Salty Caramel Pretzel/ Classic Chocolate ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and rich chocolate syrup, topped with chocolate covered pretzel rod.

  • Chocolate Covered Strawberry

    Naturally flavored strawberry ice cream with bits of real strawberry, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Chocolate Monkey Shake

    Classic Chocolate ice cream, blended with a real banana.

  • Chocolate Skippy

    Classic Chocolate/ Chocolate PB ice cream, mixed with extra creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • Coco-Oh Rum

    Rum ice cream with real raisins, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Cocoa-Coconut

    Smooth and creamy coconut ice cream, blended with rich chocolate syrup,topped with coconut flakes.

  • Coffee Toffee

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with Heath Bar, Butterscotch sauce, topped with whipped cream, Butterscotch and dusting of Heath Bar.

  • Creamsicle

    Justine’s signature shake, created in 1989. A flavorful Vanilla/Orange blend, mixed with secret ingredient and orange juice.

  • Creamy Lemon Pie

    Rich and creamy vanilla soft serve/ Lemon ice cream, blended with graham crackers, topped with whipped cream and dusting of graham crackers.

  • Express Shake

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with a shot of Italian Espresso, topped with whipped cream.

  • Expresso De Leche

    Dolche De Leche ice cream, blended with a freshly made Italian espresso.

  • German Chocolate Shake

    Justine’s specialty mix of ice creams, blended with rich hot fudge sauce, topped with whipped cream.

  • Hot Chocolate Shake

    Rich Classic Chocolate ice cream, blended with Cayenne, topped with dusting of Cayenne. Optional mix-in – extra Cayenne.

  • Hot Fudge Sundae Shake

    Chocolate Chip ice cream, blended with rich hot fudge sauce and malt, topped with whipped cream and a cherry.

  • Key Lime Shake

    Refreshing Lemon/Lime ice cream, blended with graham crackers, topped with whipped cream and dusting of graham crackers.

  • Latte Express

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean, blended with a shot of Italian Espresso.

  • Madras Shake

    Raspberry and Orange sorbet, blended with seltzer water. A diary free shake.

  • Mandarin Shake

    Classic chocolate mixed with orange juice.

  • Millennium

    Peach flavor with bits of peaches, blended with fresh orange juice.

  • Mint Chocolate Covered Oreo

    Mint/ Oreo’s ice cream mix, blended with rich chocolate syrup and extra Oreo’s.

  • Mocha Express

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with a shot of Italian espresso.

  • Mocha Shake

    Rich coffee flavored ice cream, blended with delicious chocolate syrup.

  • Mud Slide

    Espresso ice cream with espresso chocolatey chips, blended with Oreo’s, rich hot fudge sauce and a shot of Italian espresso, topped with whipped cream and Oreo’s.

  • Orange Freeze

    Refreshing blend of Rainbow Sherbet and orange juice.

  • Peach Melba Shake

    Peach/Raspberry ice cream mix with bits of peaches, blended with rich chocolate syrup.

  • Peanut Butter Covered Pretzel

    Vanilla/Peanut Butter ice cream, blended with crunchy pretzels and creamy peanut butter, topped with peanut butter covered pretzel rod.

  • Peanut Butter Jelly Shake

    Vanilla/PB ice cream, blended with strawberry sauce and creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • Pina Colada

    Exquisite blend of Coconut/Pineapple, topped with coconut flakes, whipped cream and a cherry.

  • Sinnamon Toast

    Vanilla Bean/Cinnamon mix, blended with graham crackers, topped with extra graham crackers, whipped cream and dusting of cinnamon.

  • Vanilla Monkey Shake

    Vanilla ice cream with flecks of real vanilla bean,blended with a real banana.

  • Vanilla Skippy Shake

    Vanilla/Peanut Butter ice cream, mixed with extra creamy peanut butter sauce.

  • White & Black

    Classic chocolate, blended with luscious vanilla syrup.

  • Wild Bull

    Rich classic chocolate ice cream blended with root beer syrup.



soft serve

Soft Serve Ice Cream

  • VANILLA

    Vanilla flavored, premium 10% butterfat soft serve ice cream.

  • CHOCOLATE

    Chocolate flavored, premium 10% butterfat soft serve ice cream.

  • TWIST

    Twist of vanilla and chocolate flavored, premium 10% butterfat soft serve ice cream.

Hurricanes

Blend of rich soft serve ice cream and three mix-ins, served in a 16 oz cup. Check toppings list.

  • Vanilla

    An amazing mix of 10 % butterfat Vanilla Soft Serve ice cream, mixed with three toppings.

  • Chocolate

    An amazing blend of 10 % butterfat Chocolate Soft Serve ice cream, mixed with three toppings.

  • Twist

    A delightful blend of 10 % butterfat Vanilla/Chocolate Twist Soft Serve ice cream, mixed with three toppings.

A Twist on Tradition: The History of Soft Serve

Over Memorial Day weekend of 1934, Tom Carvel, the founder of the Carvel brand and franchise, suffered a flat tire in his ice cream truck in Hartsdale, New York. He pulled into a parking lot and began selling his melting ice cream to vacationers driving by. Within two days he had sold his entire supply of ice cream and concluded that both a fixed location and soft (as opposed to hard) frozen desserts were potentially good business ideas.

Dairy Queen also claims to have invented soft serve. In 1938, near Moline, Illinois, J.F. McCullough and his son, Alex, developed their soft serve formula.Their first sales experiment was August 4, 1938, in Kankakee, Illinois at the store of theirfriend, Sherb Noble.



toppings

At Justine’s Ice Cream Parlour in Ocean City, we offer a delightful selection of both dry and wet toppings to customize your sundae or hurricane to perfection. Each sundae and hurricane comes with a generous number of complimentary toppings, with additional toppings available for a  extra charge. Create your dream treat with endless possibilities of sweet, crunchy, and flavorful additions!

Dry Toppings

  • Chocolate Sprinkles/Jimmies

  • Chopped Peanuts

  • Coconut Flakes

  • Graham Crackers

  • Gummy Bears

  • Maraschino Cherries

  • M&Ms

  • Oreo’s

  • Pretzels

  • Rainbow Sprinkles/Jimmies

  • Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

  • Reese’s Pieces

  • Heath Bar Crunch

Wet Toppings

  • Chocolate Syrup

  • Caramel

  • Hot Fudge

  • Marshmallow

  • Butterscotch

  • Peanut Butter

  • Strawberry

  • Pineapple

  • Wet Nuts

  • Whipped Cream



Craving a snow cone? Treat yourself to 16 amazing flavors at Justine’s Ice Cream Parlour in Ocean City and enjoy a refreshing, flavorful experience with every bite!

Snow Cone Flavors

  • Banana

  • Blue Raspberry

  • Cherry

  • Chocolate

  • Coconut

  • Egg Custard

  • Grape

  • Lemon

  • Marshmallow (extra charge)

  • Orange

  • Red Raspberry

  • Root Beer

  • Spearmint

  • Strawberry

  • Vanilla

  • Watermelon

Snow Cones during the Industrial Revolution

Justinesoc-snow-cones
In the 1850s the American Industrial Revolution made ice commercially available. Ice houses in New York would commonly sell ice to places like Florida. To transport the ice to Florida, the ice houses would send a wagon with a huge block of ice south. The route to Florida would pass right through Baltimore. In Baltimore, children would run up to the wagon and ask for a small scraping of ice. Before long, mothers started to make flavoring in anticipation of their child receiving some ice. The first flavor these mothers made was a current Baltimore favorite: egg custard. Egg custard was an easy flavor to make as all that was in it was eggs, vanilla and sugar.

Snow Cones during the Great Depression and World War II

During the Great Depression and World War II, snowballs came to be available outside of Baltimore. As snowballs were so cheap, they were one of the few treats that people could afford. This inexpensiveness earned snowballs the nicknames “Hard Times Sundae” and “Penny Sundae”. People in need of a job would sell snowballs as it required little overhead. The treat became more popular during World War II, when all available ice cream was sent to soldiers, creating a need for an icy treat. This new found lack of competition helped snowballs became popular across the country.

In Hawaii, “shave ice” is similar to snowballs, and is sold in cone-shaped paper cups. “Rainbow,” a popular flavor, consists of three colors of syrup chosen usually for their color rather than their taste compatibility. Commonly, a scoop of vanilla ice cream or sweetened azuki beans is first added to the bottom of the cup and is capped with condensed milk



fudge

Our fudge is made in-house. We use high quality ingredients in the process of making. All of our flavors are made with real butter and cream.

Every week we change some of the flavors and offer some new flavor.Not all of the flavors listed below are available through the season.
If you have any questions regarding availability of a fudge flavor,please give us a call on:
410 250 5003 before you visit us.

Homemade Fudge

  • Chocolate

  • Chocolate with M&Ms

  • Chocolate-Peanut Butter

  • Chocolate Strawberry*

  • Chocolate with Reese’s Pieces

  • Chocolate Walnut

  • Cookies & Cream

  • Dark Chocolate

  • Dark Peanut Butter Explosion

  • Heath Bar Toffee

  • Orange*

  • Peanut Butter

  • Peanut Butter Explosion

  • Rainbow Sherbet*

  • Raspberry*

  • Strawberry*

  • Sweet & Salty Caramel Pretzel

  • Tiger Butter

  • Vanilla

* – When Available

Fudge History

American-style fudge is discovered in a short letter written by Emelyn Battersby Hartridge, who was a student at Vassar College in Poughkeepsie, New York. She wrote that her schoolmate’s cousin made fudge in Baltimore, Maryland. Hartridge obtained the fudge recipe and, in 1888, made fudge for the Vassar College Senior Auction. This recipe became quite popular at the school for years to come.

Word of this popular confectionery spread to other women’s colleges.

In the late 19th century, shops on Mackinac Island in Michigan began to produce similar products for summer vacationers.